How do you you know when you are ready to go off anti-depressant medication?

I had a client come in to see me today whom I had not seen for some time. She was wanting to touch base about going off her anti-depressant medication which she had been on for about a year. She wondered whether it was right timing and was worried that if she went off, her old symptoms could return. Not unlike many, she had started her journey on medication rather reluctantly, feeling as if she had failed in some way because she had not been able to manage her symptoms on her own. Yet, she could not deny that the medication had really helped her and had made a significant difference to her quality of life. She started the session off by saying: “You have to write a blog on how do you really know if you are better?” My thought was, this is a really good question to write about as I have been asked it many times. After all, when medication has been containing symptoms for a long time, how can one predict whether or not they will reappear once the medication has worn off?

Most physicians these days will suggest that if you go on an anti-depressant medication for anxiety or depression that you stay on it for about a year. This is because empirical research has shown that while you might feel considerably better after a couple of months, it is best to stay the course for another 4 to 5 months if you want to avoid relapse. Once you have done this though, and you have been feeling good for quite awhile, how do you know when it is time to try doing without? For some, it is a scary venture and some reassurance would be nice. Unfortunately, the answer is that while you can up the ante on being successful, you never really know how you will do without medication until you put it to the test.

It is definitely wise not to go off medication when you are in a crisis or major transition. It is also not a great idea to go off medication if you live in Manitoba and it is the middle of winter! Another rule of thumb is that it is best to wean off medication gradually rather than going off cold turkey. That way you can avoid adjustment reactions. If your physician does not offer you guidance on this, pharmacists are often very knowledgeable about methods that work best for weaning off medication. How you will fare, however, is often only discernible through the practice of trial and error. If you don’t get a re-occurrence of symptoms, you are O.K. to go. If you do, then more likely than not, you have weaned off prematurely and need to stay the course for a while longer. When you go off, do not make the mistake of expecting to be able to assess in a couple of days or even a week whether there has been any negative fall out. It can take a good month before you might be able to determine how you are faring without medication.

Anti-depressant medications work by accumulating in your system. It takes 4 to 6 weeks to determine whether an anti-depressant medication is effective and so, it will take at least that long for it to leave your system so that you can properly assess how you feel without it. If you go off and intrusive symptoms come back in a disconcerting way, do yourself a favor and don’t beat yourself up about it. Appreciate instead that you have learned that the medication was in fact helping you. When you have been on medication for a year or more, it may well be hard to tell if it is having any impact at all. Also, appreciate that there is medicine that can help you and go about the task of adding to your repertoire of positive coping skills and making some lifestyle changes ( i.e., exercise, proper diet, good life/work balance). If you have been on medication and you have not seen a therapist, know that the research is consistent. People whose symptoms are severe enough to warrant medication have the best long-term results if they not only take medication but do therapy as well. This only makes sense when you think about it. Medication can only reduce the intensity of your the symptoms. It cannot address the source of your problems; nor can it help you to learn better coping skills. Also know that about one quarter of people who go on anti-depressant medication will need to stay on it long-term; they may even have to stay on it for life. These often are the people who have struggled with depression/anxiety since childhood or adolescence and where there is a strong family history and thus, biochemical aspect to their illness.

As a psychologist, I would say that I am fairly conservative when it comes to suggesting medication. After all, my specialty is helping clients get to the root of their problem and in teaching people better coping skills not, psycho-pharmacology. I do know a lot about how medications work because often I see clients over time and on a more regular basis than their physician would. In the United States, some psychologists prescribe medication. If the truth be told, I would prefer not to. I have learned, however, through experience not to be close-minded about the benefits of medication. As many seasoned therapists know, sometimes a client’s symptoms are so severe that psychological methods will not work without a biochemical assist to help them get onto more stable ground. When symptoms have become severe and unwieldy; for example, when a person is suffering severe panic attacks or is unable to focus, think clearly or process information properly, a therapist cannot be effective in using talk therapy alone. Sometimes, this is evident from the start because the symptoms are so clearly overwhelming. At other times, the therapist and client have given therapy a shot and it becomes apparent that they will be stalled until the symptoms are no longer so crippling. When such is the case, recommending that a client consult with their doctor about the advisability of giving medication a trial to decrease the intensity of their symptoms is the number one priority. Contrary to what some might think, anti-depressant medication will not make you into a “zombie”. In fact, if you go on medication and feel like you have gone numb or your emotional world has become flat, then more than likely, you are on the wrong medication. Medication is also not a “happy pill”. When an anti-depressant medication works well, it takes the edge off symptoms and in fact provides a window of opportunity for therapy to be effective. This is when the two, talking therapy and medication, interface in the most ideal way.

1 Comment

  • Merika Skirko

    The subtitle to this excellent and very useful article could be “when would I need to be open to trying an anti-depressant?” There is understandable reluctance and misinformation on medication. Your article breaks down some of the fears, and explains what meds can and can’t do.

  • Write a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Blog Archives